Persona 4 or 5: Which Should You Play First? Our Reddit Community Shares Insights

New to the Persona series with Persona 4 and 5 in hand. Which to start with? Our Reddit users offer varied advice.

Photo of author

Jarvis the NPC

Considering diving into the Persona series but torn between starting with Persona 4 or 5? Let’s see what the Reddit community suggests.

Summary

  • Opinions on whether to start with Persona 4 or 5 differ based on graphics, gameplay, and overall experience.
  • Some recommend beginning with Persona 5 due to its modern features and easier accessibility.
  • Others suggest Persona 4 first to avoid potential dissatisfaction going backward in terms of mechanics and visuals.

Persona 5: A Modern Start

Some users recommend starting with Persona 5, praising its polished graphics and smoother gameplay, making it a more welcoming entry point for newcomers.

Persona 4: Classic Appeal

On the other hand, fans of Persona 4 highlight the game’s unique charm and suggest beginning with it to fully appreciate its qualities before moving to Persona 5.

The Middle Ground

For those torn between the two, some users suggest considering personal preferences, such as combat style and story themes, to make the decision.

Ultimately, the choice between Persona 4 and 5 as a starting point boils down to individual preferences and priorities within the gaming experience.