Skull and Bones: Honest Feedback from Beta Players and the Pirate Community

Players provide honest feedback on Skull and Bones beta, expressing mixed feelings about missing features and gameplay mechanics.

Photo of author

Jarvis the NPC

Skull and Bones has been creating quite a buzz in the gaming community since its beta launch, and players have wasted no time in sharing their thoughts on the game. One Reddit post, titled "Honest feedback after playing non stop since beta launch," has sparked a heated discussion among fans. Let’s dive into what players are saying and how the game measures up to their expectations.

Summary:

  • Missing key features from its predecessor, Black Flag
  • Some players enjoy the simplified mechanics and focus on ship battles
  • Concerns raised about lack of depth and repetitive gameplay
  • Hope for future DLC and improvements to make the game more fleshed out

Missing the Mark:

One player, zombiegamer87, believes that Skull and Bones fell short in capturing the essence of pirate gameplay. They point out several missing features from Black Flag, such as no swordplay, swimming, diving, and ship boarding. The player is disappointed by the reliance on quick-time events (QTEs) for resource gathering, calling it lazy game design. They express hope for future updates and DLC to address these shortcomings.

In response to this critique, DumplingsCosby counters with some valid points. They argue that adding hand-to-hand combat and boarding mechanics could detract from the core ship battles, which many players find enjoyable. They also raise concerns about player versus player (PvP) interactions and resource gathering, suggesting that keeping the focus on ship battles saves time and prevents complications.

Two Sides of the Coin:

Tyler1997117 chimes in, reminding players that Skull and Bones isn’t meant to be a direct sequel to Black Flag. While it shares some similarities in combat, the game aims to offer a unique pirate experience.

Shiirooo also offers a different perspective, acknowledging that the game may sound appealing in theory but could become repetitive in practice. They suggest trying Black Flag to understand the potential monotony of the gameplay loop.

Looking Beyond Skull and Bones:

Aaron_Dark_sos takes the opportunity to praise Sea of Thieves as the best multiplayer pirate game, expressing a desire for it to come to the PS5 in the future.

Overall, opinions on Skull and Bones seem divided. Some players appreciate the focus on ship battles and simplified mechanics, while others yearn for the depth and variety offered by Black Flag. The hope for future updates and DLC to address these concerns is evident, as players eagerly await a more fleshed-out pirate experience. Only time will tell if Skull and Bones can live up to players’ expectations and become the ultimate pirate game. So, grab your cutlass and set sail, because the world of Skull and Bones awaits you!